Elliptical vs. Treadmill: Which Suits Your Fitness Goals?

GYMSPORTZ PTE LTD | 10 June 2025

Choosing the right cardio machine can make a big difference to your fitness journey. For many in Singapore, limited space and specific health goals make selecting between an elliptical trainer and a treadmill more than just a matter of preference. Both machines offer excellent cardiovascular workouts, but the benefits and drawbacks of each can vary depending on your needs, available space, and personal preferences.

Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which machine is better suited for your goals.

Impact on joints and injury prevention

One of the key differences between an elliptical and a treadmill lies in how they affect your joints. Elliptical trainers provide a low-impact workout, which means your feet never leave the pedals. This reduces stress on the knees, ankles, and hips, making it a great option for users with joint concerns, previous injuries, or those recovering from physiotherapy.

On the other hand, treadmills involve continuous foot-striking motion, which may lead to higher impact on the joints, especially when running. However, if walking is your primary form of exercise, the impact is minimal and often manageable for most users. If joint health is a priority, or you're easing back into exercise, the elliptical may be more forgiving on your body.

Calorie burn and weight loss

When it comes to burning calories, both machines are highly effective, but the treadmill often has the edge. Running on a treadmill typically burns more calories per minute than using an elliptical, simply because it requires more exertion and engages more muscles at a higher intensity.

That said, elliptical machines can still offer excellent calorie-burning workouts, especially when resistance and incline are adjusted. Plus, they allow for full-body engagement when handles are used, involving the upper body more than a standard treadmill workout. If your goal is rapid fat loss, and you're up for high-intensity workouts, the treadmill may give you quicker results.

Muscle engagement and strength

While both machines target the lower body, the elliptical often provides a more balanced workout by incorporating the arms, chest, and back through the moving handles. It can also improve coordination and core stability when used properly.

Treadmills, meanwhile, predominantly work the lower body muscles like quads, hamstrings, calves, and glutes. Using incline settings can enhance this effect, simulating uphill walking or running for added strength-building benefits. If you're looking to tone your entire body and increase upper body involvement, the elliptical could be the better choice.

Space and convenience at home

Living in Singapore often means dealing with limited home space, especially in HDB flats or smaller condos. In this case, the size and portability of your equipment become important factors. Ellipticals tend to have a larger footprint, while some treadmills offer folding designs to save space. If you're considering a compact treadmill, you may find it easier to fit in your living area or store away after use.

Additionally, treadmill rental options are available in Singapore for those who prefer to try before they purchase or want a temporary solution without a full investment. This flexibility can be appealing if you’re not yet sure which machine is best for your long-term needs.

Workout variety and motivation

Keeping workouts interesting is key to maintaining motivation. Treadmills usually offer a range of speed and incline settings, and many come with built-in workout programmes to simulate hill sprints, interval training, or endurance runs. For those who enjoy outdoor running but want the convenience of staying indoors during hot or rainy days, a treadmill is a solid substitute.

Elliptical machines also come with preset workouts and resistance levels, and they allow you to pedal in reverse, which activates different muscle groups. This variety can help prevent workout boredom and promote muscle balance over time.

Fitness goals and user preferences

Ultimately, the right machine for you depends on your specific fitness goals. If you're training for a marathon or enjoy walking and running, the treadmill aligns well with your interests. It's also a strong option for those focusing on calorie burn and lower-body conditioning.

If you're aiming for low-impact cardio, full-body toning, or need something joint-friendly, the elliptical may be a better fit. Beginners, seniors, or users recovering from injuries might also find it easier to start with an elliptical trainer due to its gentler motion.

The final decision

When deciding between an elliptical and a treadmill, consider what fits your fitness level, space constraints, and personal preferences. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but understanding the pros and cons of each machine will help you make a more informed choice. If possible, try both types of equipment in person before committing.

Gymsportz offers a wide range of both elliptical machines and treadmills, including space-saving and feature-rich models that suit all kinds of home setups. Explore our full collection and find the ideal fitness companion for your health goals by visiting Gymsportz.

BLOGS